Was what Trump did wrong?
Italic= shining brain 1 (host)
Was what Trump did wrong?
Hey my fellow bnc how are you today? We have a very special guest with us today who will be helping us disscuss a really serious issue.
person 1: the issue is: Is what Trump did wrong? For all the people who do not know what has happened Trump bombed Iran and eneded up killing their genral.
Thats right and we are going to be disscussing if what he did was worth it and if it was all messed up.
person 4: Personally i think what he did was wrong. Iran did nothing to him and he killed their Genaral because he thought that they would be Compitetion.
lets hear from other children around the world. caller 1 wishes to stay annonymous.
caller 1: i think what he did was ok because he did it to protect his people.
But do you think protecting your people needs you to kill others?
Caller 1: no but it was what trump thought would be best. He probably thought it would make Iran scared to face America.
Wow what you said makes a lot of sense. lets here from another person. Here is another child who wishes for us to call them G.
G: i think what he did was wrong becaus iran did nothing to him or any other allies and one perso payed for his actions!
i think most people agree with the same thing... Iran did nothing to him so he shouldnt have done it but is there any diffrent tesons on why he shouldnt of done it?
...
well i guess we have to rap it u-
ring...
well that proves me wrong sombody eles wants to make point.
unkown caller 1: well i think it was wrong because 1st of all trump could have caused deaths to not just the genral but to lotsof other people.
that is very true!
unkown caller 1: i also think it is wrong to kill anybody, from gernrals to cleaners!
welp i think its time to wrap it up. i will see you for a part two next time.
Comments (41)
10 Jan 2020
Thank you for this, shining_brain. We've approved it as it is about the actions of a politician and whether it is right / wrong. This is a very complex area and there's much more knowledge to learn than what's in your post, so for everyone, this is a very good explanation of the situation: https://www.bbc.co.uk/newsround/51031097
Well Tom, that was very thought-out.
10 Jan 2020
What trump did was disgraceful because he didn't have the right to go and 1.bomb Iran and 2. kill there general.this is not all trump has done wrong.Ithink people should be thing about how people have died just because trump did not like Iran.Even though the way Iran has reacted was terrible.The way Iran has attacked U.S.A is by attacking Irack which is a neighbour to Iran.I think the way this is going it is just going to be a noncivilised.But Iran does not have any nuclear weapons.
your right! if Iran doesn't have any nuclear weapons what could that do to them? will it make the situation worst?
your a good righter but tell me more
10 Jan 2020
so what Trump did that know everyone hates him was that he killed a man with a rocket and know everyone is angry and trying to kill him
can you this sentence make more sense so i can read it? I didn't know people wanted to kill him so thanks for the information!
I think your right observant_jambul's because in his time Donald trump has killed a lot of people when he started to be a prime minister and trump build a wall to spit Mexico .
10 Jan 2020
I definitely think what Trump did was wrong because people have a right to live even if they did wrong ,plus that's Trumps second time killing someone. 1.He killed someone from London(England) using a rocket,as apparently he was a killer. But he doesn't need to but into our country's life , his country is miles away so it's not fair. 2. He killed the leader of the army in Iraq as quoted in BBC News"I want WAR" (that is what Donald Trump answered) THIS IS NOT FAIR!!!!!
sorry i wasn't so up-to-date on the news but when did he kill somebody from London? and why did he do that?
No, it was not from London, but an army general in Iran. You can read more about it here: https://www.bbc.co.uk/newsround/50982493
10 Jan 2020
You should not kill someone because that is not fair at all!!!!!!!!
this is right, can u say more?
10 Jan 2020
All the world should live in peace! We should all treat each other nicely!
but what if we lived in peace would that be better?
10 Jan 2020
He is MEAN!
tell me more, use more descriptive words
13 Jan 2020
Everything that he has done is wrong
can you give me an example?
14 Jan 2020
I think what Trump did was wrong because he killed someone who did nothing to him, all he wanted to do was to protect his country and make it a better and safer place. Trump had no right.
your right. They wouldn't like it if Iran killed the person who means the most to them
How can it mean the most to them if they probably have not even met them in real life and he wanted to make a war.
true!can you explain futher?
Trump had no right to kill Iran because he was innocent and had done nothing to him back or in the first place. So he shouldn't have done that.
15 Jan 2020
donald trump wants to take over the big countryes so he get more money to than eney countreyes
15 Jan 2020
why do we hate him well he wants to make people more hate him
15 Jan 2020
yeah
I think you really could of written more.
That has a lot of interesting reasons and very good importance
16 Jan 2020
I don't understand, in 2018 Donald Trump posted he wants to live in WORLD PEACE and 2 years later he orders his army to kill the Iranians General knowing Iran makes nuclear weapons. So he gets attacked, it is his fault.
16 Jan 2020
Donald Trump killed the Iran leader
He killed the Iranian's General
yeah but the leader wanted a war
Donald trump killed the iran leader
16 Jan 2020
I don't think it is ever okay to kill someone, even if they are a terrorist. We don't like terrorists because they kill people, so why is it okay for Donald Trump to send a drone to kill someone in another country?
16 Jan 2020
I think that Trump was wrong because he had send a bomb to Iraq and he said that he might send a nuclear bomb and wipe out Iraq, In addition ,he had already send a bomb to Iraq and killed the leader coming along with his children and the people in Iraq wre sad because he was killed and his children.
Can you clarify if you’re talking about Iraq or Iran?
21 Jan 2020
I think that what he did is not wrong because that person in Iran wanted to do a war and a lot of people want peace in the world.
04 Feb 2020
Why did Donald Trump build the wall
07 Feb 2020
I don't know reflective glacier but I would want to know
👍✔
07 Feb 2020
aswell
You must be logged in with Student Hub access to post a comment. Sign up now!