Border or Border-less? (What are, both, the positives and negatives of the border?)


Border or Border-less? (What are some of the negatives and positives of the barrier?)

To begin with, this article will be about: ‘’What are the benefits and disadvantages of building the American border?’’ and ‘’Should Trump go through with his decision?’’ This topic is quite debateable and there will be, both, opinion and fact. This article will cover:

-Key definitions.

-Positives of the wall

-Negatives of the wall.

-My opinion.

Firstly, some of these words will be mentioned within this page that you may not understand:

-Border/wall- A fence or wall separating something, so that there is seclusion on both sides. (In this case, Donald Trump would be separating himself and America from Mexico.)

-Positive reason- A good or enlightened term used for something which could benefit something else.

-Negative reason- A pessimistic term used for something which is not benefitting something else.

-Migration- Leaving one area to live in another.

-Populism- Some people may feel as if their requests have been ignored by important agencies.

-Consensus- A survey or vote which indicates what the public would like to happen.

What does Donald Trump want to achieve? Many sources state that the information is limited on what Trump would like to achieve (on building the wall), but some sites suggest that; Donald Trump would like to prevent immigrants from going into the country, freely. Many news reports state that, Trump is unsure of what he would like to achieve, only that the money he would get, would go to the wall. Sources, also, mentioned that too many people are crossing the southern border illegally and that Donald Trump may be trying to prohibit that from occurring.

Background information on the wall: The wall, in question, would be around two thousand miles long, proceeding through; New Mexico and Texas. Trump, the American president, had wanted to build this wall for a substantial amount of time but he needed agencies to accept his offer, and provide him with the money. Recently, Trump has been talking about the wall as the Congress may finally accept his offer. The border, overall, would cost around $5.7 billion, (According to some extracts, both, America and Mexico will have to pay.) I can infer that, perhaps Trump wanted to build a wall by examining other successes.

Leading on, there are many sources which state that building the wall, would be an excellent idea. To start with, many statistics show that having a border may be beneficial to the American citizens as it would be a barrier of protection from illegal activity. If the border had been built, some Americans may feel safer as they may feel enclosed and not available to the public. An example of an unlawful act could be, illegal immigration. Some people may try to migrate and not register as a citizen to avoid paying tax, working or helping the country at all. Illegal immigration costs a lot of money as (if someone is not paying tax) there is less money going to the government to help support education, medical facilities, etc. Lastly, a study from ‘ThoughtCo’’ suggested that ‘There would be less strain on the government.’ However, we must ask ourselves if, ‘’Everyone would feel safe?’’

In contrast, many people believe that the negative reasons outweigh the positives. Critics argue that, even if the wall was built, people would still find other ways to get in to America. (It would be close to impossible to keep Mexicans out of the country as they would find ways around it.) This relates to; if the wall failed to serve its purpose, then authorities may question, ‘Why did we fund this, if it was doomed to fail?’ Another reason as to why the wall would not benefit anyone would be; If Trump’s purpose was to stop Mexicans from getting into the country, he would perhaps get demonized for it as some Americans may not agree with his decision. This could relate to populism as if Trump is only doing what he would like, the Americans may feel ignored or disregarded and (perhaps) they may start to rebel. However, this could be prevented if Trump had given his people a consensus. He could then plan based on either the majority or certain individuals (he would be giving everyone a fair chance.) If he, also, shared his ideas with the public, he could improve his original idea to prevent failure.

To conclude; my opinion; I believe that Trump should listen to his audience but, on the other hand, he is responsible for making the decisions so I believe he is trying to protect his country, even if it may not be fair to everyone.

Thank you for reading! Please leave your comments below, as I would like to hear what you think!

Links for the websites I have used:

Comments (5)

  • Tiff-Avatar.jpg Tiff @ Topical Talk
    23 Apr 2019

    Have a look at this data analysis website and see if you can use the information to help inform your opinion about the American public's view point.

    Reply to this comment
  • swedish school.JPG coherent_fruit | Skellefteå
    29 Apr 2019

    This was a good one thanks powerful_robin
    Its good that you had a word description that helps a lot

    Reply to this comment
  • Birchwood-logo-250x250.jpg plucky_cat | Birchwood C of E Primary School | United Kingdom
    30 Apr 2019

    I think that the wall is bad idea. What Donald Trump is doing is blaming one group of people (immigrants) for problems that exist in the country he is leading. His supporters believe what he is saying and therefore think that building a wall is a good idea. He bleives that illegal immigration costs the united states billions of dollars, IN early December he said that it cost $250 billion ayear, later in December he said that it cost more than $200 billion a year and then at the endof December he said it cost $275 billion a year. We could infer from this that even Donald Trump isn't sure how much it actually costs. Opponents to Trump esitimated in 2013 the cost of undocumented immigrants — the cost of services received minus their tax contributions — was about $54 billion a year; considerably less.
    This reminds me of the issues around Brexit - people were saying that it would save the UK millions of pounds but it wasn't proven and the actual costs are still unknown.

    Reply to this comment
    1. balloon.png Rose @ the BNC
      plucky_cat's comment 30 Apr 2019

      Well done for this post. I like how you have linked your thoughts on this issue with the last issue on Brexit. Where did you get all your facts and figures from?

      Reply to this comment
  • Birchwood-logo-250x250.jpg plucky_cat | Birchwood C of E Primary School | United Kingdom
    10 May 2019

    I got some information from Trump wall - all you need to know about US border in seven charts ... and I forgot where i got how much we money costs

    Reply to this comment

You must be logged in with Student Hub access to post a comment. Sign up now!