Is Elon Musk's power a problem?
This post was written by a student. It has not been fact checked or edited.
Elon Musk is the worlds richest person having a total estimated net worth of 400 billion dollars. He is an well-renowned entrepreneur and engineer known for leading Tesla, SpaceX, Neuralink, Spacelink and xAI. More recently, on April 14th 2022 he bought the social media platform twitter and since then it has been rebranded to X. Musk holds a great amount of influence and has garnered a massive 200 million followers on his platform. He has also developed a realationship with President Trump, now serving as his senior advisor. Also, he is said to have 'interfered' in global politics sparking debates about his power.
Elon Musks power can be a problem in several ways. You could say that he has too much influence over critical industries that have huge impact on the world. For example, in 2022 after Russia invaded Ukraine, Ukraine suffered severe internet and communication blackouts. Musk intervened by providing Starlink terminals to help Ukraine maintain internet access for civilians, governments and the military. Starlink became essential for military coordination, drone operations and internet access for civilians. In 2023, there were reports that SpaceX blocked Ukraine from using Starlink for military offensive operations. Musk's justification was that he didn't want Starlink being used for war escalation and that it was a peaceful means o communication. He argued that allowing such operations it would make SpaceX an active participant in war. This decision was met with backlash. Many critisised Musk for interfering in international conflict by effectively making military decisions himself and resulted in Ukraine's fustration and U.S. officials concerns about Musk having too much power over critical technology. This incident raised questions about whether a single company or person should cotrol such essential technology in conflicts. Some argued that goverenments should own or regualte military-critical commuications and not rely on private companies. Others stated that Musk's decisions had real world military consequences, even though he was not an elected official and Starlink’s control over internet access in war zones could set a dangerous precedent for future conflicts.
The Starlink-Ukraine controversy showed has powerful Musk has become. His decions directly impacted a war. While Musk said he wanted to avoid escalation, critics argue he overstepped by making geopolitical decisions that affected an entire country’s war effort. Ulimately, Musk is both an innovator and disruptor. His power is like a double-edged sword, capable of pushing humanity forward but also posing risks if left uncheched. The future depends on whether governments and competitors can keep his influence in check or if he remains to be one of the most powerful and unpredictable figures of modern times.
Comments (10)
Elon Musk's influence has sparked debate on whether it poses a problem. On one hand, Musk has revolutionised industries with companies like Tesla and SpaceX, pushing for innovation in electric vehicles, space exploration, and renewable energy. However, his dominance in these fields, along with his role in shaping public discourse through platforms like Twitter (now X), raises concerns.
Critics argue that Musk's immense wealth and power enable him to shape markets, policy, and media narratives. His actions can sway stock prices, influence political debates, and impact the global economy, often with limited accountability. Musk's unconventional leadership style and occasional controversial statements further complicate this image of power. His ability to make decisions impacting millions, without oversight or transparency, raises questions about the concentration of corporate power and its ethical implications.
While Musk has demonstrated visionary leadership, the potential risks of such concentrated influence—whether it’s on technological progress, public trust, or societal values—are real. Balancing innovation with ethical responsibility and accountability is crucial in ensuring his power doesn’t become a problem.
Elon Musk is a very powerful and influential person that his decisions have an impact worldwide. Apart from being an awesome entrepreneur, he is also the world's richest person which just serves to make him more valuable and an inspiration to many. With over 200 million followers on X (formerly Twitter), he is one of the most powerful voices on social media, that means his every casual post or even jokes can misinterpreted and lead to serious decisions. Critics argue that his unsupervised influence can spread wrong information and biased views.
And I agree with this post. In 2022, when the Russia - Ukraine war started, Elon Musk's company SpaceX provided starlink with internet terminals to help Ukraine to maintain communication. But in 2023, Elon Musk denied Ukraine's access to starlink for "offensive military operations". Offensive military operations like when Ukraine planned attack on Russian ships in Crimea. Later on, Elon Musk defended himself by saying that he denied Ukraine's access to starlink because he did NOT want starlink to be used in war cases like this and it could make SpaceX a direct participant. This action also resulted into criticisim from Ukraine officials and US people, raising concern about a PRIVATE individual (Elon Musk) controlling important war infrastructure.
In my eyes, Elon Musk embodies the role of a disruptor. While his technologies and companies (e.g. SpaceX, the Boring Company, Neuralink) have advanced the technological race, his policies are impulsive and his power is just far too big. He almost stopped Starlink in Ukraine, this wasn't just a simple business decision. It could've completely disrupted military operations, civilian survival and medical assistance in a warzone. X (formerly Twitter) has some less than ideal policies regarding hate speech. His reinstatement of multiple banned accounts has really questioned how well he moderates X. Putting so much power in one person's hands raises questions about ethics, monopolies and global accountability. Musk has once openly criticized a charity, and due to his comments, the workers were harrassed. It seemed deeply personal and like he just hated the charity. It wasn't controlled. It was impulsive. Something which nobody with great power should rely on. So, in my eyes, Elon Musk is a disruptor, who embodies the concept of chaos. A force that no one can control, capable of both good and bad.
I completely agree with this comment. Elon Musk's immense power and influence have been both positive and negative consequences. His actions, particularly in the case of Ukraine conflict, show the complexity of his role in global affairs. While Musk's technological innovations have advanced many industries, his decisions- like limiting Starlink's use in military operations- demonstrate the dangers of allowing one individual to control such critical infrastructure. This situation raises important ethical questions about the concentration of power in private hands, especially when it involves military or political implications. Musk's impulsive nature and lack of oversight show that unchecked power can have serious consequences, which should be carefully considered especially in such high stake's scenarios.
Thank You
I think Elon Musk power might not be a problem yet, Elon Musk, the richest person on the world Elon net worth is around 400 billion and his money came from Tesla, X and many more, his influence sometime cause problem Elon Musk was chosen to be Trump advisor Elon Musk follower has reach 200 million on every post can influence stock price and shape media narratives Elon Musk was frame for misinformation where he been criticized for his misleading claims about Social Security payouts to deceased individual. One time on his post about the German elections and other political topics have been flagged for spreading false information. Elon Musk and Trump administration have made exaggerated claims about millions of dead people receiving Social Security payments, the number Musk cited were significantly.
I disagree because I believe his power is problematic. During the war between Russia and Ukraine, Elon Musk told Ukraine to cede the land Russia wanted. He even threatened to cut off the Wi-Fi and satellite services he provided during the war. His own son even told Donald Trump in front of everyone to "shut up". I think this is also alarming to the fact that Elon Musk's child told the president to "shut up".
Elon Musk's influence is huge , but the real issue isn't just about him , it's about the lack of rules that let one person have so much control over critical technology. His role in the Russia- Ukraine war shows how much power private companies can hold in global conflicts, which is concerning . At the same time , companies do have the right to decide how their technology is used. Instead of focusing only on Musk , governments should create better regulations to make sure important technologies , especially those linked to security, aren't left to personal decisions . If we don't address to this now , we might see a future where unelected billionaires have more control over global conflicts than the world leaders.
Wow, Elon Musk is like the wizard of the modern world! With all that power, it's like he’s holding a magic wand that can change entire countries, like when he helped Ukraine with Starlink during the war. But here's the thing – when you have that much power, you can make decisions that affect millions of people, and sometimes, it’s like playing with fire! Musk deciding to block Starlink for military use? That’s like having a superhero who decides when to save the day, but what if they make the wrong choice? People are mad at him because he’s not a government, he’s not elected, and yet his actions shape entire wars!
It's like giving a teenager the keys to a spaceship and hoping they don’t crash it. The fact that one person, with a few clicks, can change the course of history? That's kind of scary! He’s like a chess player moving pieces on the world’s board, but not everyone agrees with his moves. Musk might be trying to keep things peaceful, but isn’t it weird that he can just step in and make a decision that changes everything? And who decides if he's right or wrong?
His power is growing, and maybe it’s time to ask ourselves, should one person have so much say in things that impact everyone, everywhere? If someone like him makes the wrong call, could it be the end of us? Would we be okay with him making more choices like this? What happens when one person has too much control?
What do you think about one person deciding so much for everyone?
I too agree and feel the same and agree on this topic that Elon Musk might just be like a wizard holding high power in this modern world.I also feel that Elon Musk has very great power not only because of his insane wealth but also his connections with supreme leaders and almost 200 million followers accross many platforms.This is like controlling a large mass of people and commanding them to perform certain tasks.This becomes worse with the ownership of A.I
It might be that Elon must be trying to make the world a better place but as said he's like playing with fire,which can turn out to be good or bad.Also as said "with great power comes great responsibility" the safety should be his priority.It will be good if he works in the welfare but if the Power is misused in the wrong direction, Things can go completely wrong.
Also as discussed Elon Musk holds great power from having millions of powers and the wealthiest person to being a literal advisor of Donald Trump the supreme leader of a superpower leading country like USA.
It's a little too scary! If you ask me to let a single person hold that high post and power.Its like he can control and take actions of millions of people and can make them do anything according to him.
Also as a developer of A.I he can also rule with the misuse of A.I and his power.
That's why it should be discussed that should one person have all this power and control accross several million people and an advisory in the USA government?
Elon's power is going to be a problem for us in the next generation and if we don't stop Elon's power his AI included companys will destroy the planet and it's surroundings. We should stop AI because with AI, humanity is outsourcing it's executive control of nearly every key sector-finance, warfare, medicine, and agriculture-to algorithms with no moral capacity. If you are wondering what could go wrong the answer is plenty. We only have one more chance to stop AI destroying our planet.
Thank you topical talk
This is the question I will answer, Is Elon Musk’s power a problem? I think Elon Musk’s power is a problem because I feel that he can do whatever he wants to America and get away with it.
He’s the president’s advisor which gives him a big advantage and a bunch of power.
His ownership of X also gives him a bunch of power and I think its making him think nobody can rule over him or stop him.
His friendship with Trump gives him the power to maybe rule over America with Trump which could give him the chance to make America a bad place.
Conclusion: I think Elon Musk’s power is corrupting him which is making him think that nobody can stop him.
Elon Musk is starting to be a bad thing for the people. One reason is that because he has power and influence in multiple aspects, and because of that it's hard to take or limit his power that he has. The future depends on whether governments and competitors can keep his influence in check or if he remains to be one of the most powerful people to this day.
Elon Musk has used his influence and power to his advantage. He uses social media (X) as a platform to spread disinformation and misinformation.At the same time swaying the opinions of others and twisting facts until they are in his favour.
It's not just opinions he is changing . He is changing real life events as well, from playing significant roles in elections to influencing a war. He can influence anybody with the click of a finger.
This is where the problem sprouts. With people saying he has too much influence over the world and people's opinions. He also has a lot of controversies surrounding the actions he has taken. Let's mention a few:
- After he acquired twitter their has been a spike of racist tweets .
- He has been accused of spreading misinformation especially regarding COVID 19 and vaccines.
- Musk's companies, especially Tesla, have faced accusations of rampant racism and sexism within their workplace
structures.
-Musk's tendency to engage in personal attacks against critics and supposed enemies has contributed to the toxic
atmosphere in public discourse
These controversies ''just to name a few'' are some of the negative things Elon Musk has used his power to do .